Summing Up
March 18th, 2008On the long flight back to the USA, I tried to encapsulate my thoughts and experiences of the remarkable two weeks we spent in the Holy Lands
Israel is exceptional. The country is modern and efficient, geared for tourists with excellent roads, facilities and hotels. The country works
The biggest change to my thinking is that the Israeli and the American Jew are not very similar - in their understanding and practice of religion, and, in their culture and way of life. I will never again think of the two synonymously. The Israeli is very aggressive, almost to the point of being uncivil. The people seem to have a siege mentality (with good reason) but the sight of young men and women, everywhere, with Uzi’s carried casually, was somewhat disconcerting. There is very tight security, everywhere, and one is never quite as ease. One characteristic common to both, is the concept of Ztdaka (s’daka), where the community looks after each other. The Mishna (holy book) prescribes the amount of grain that must be given to another - that which fills the bottom jaw of a ewe. The bible stipulates that a man must leave a quarter portion of his field unharvested, so that the poor can pick it. And other such examples are boundless. The family, community and religious culture focuses on helping the less fortunate and helping each other - each Jew is collateral to the other. I have always been very impressed with this culture - compassion and survival
Israel has an incredible biblical history and the country is dedicated to excavating and preserving it - probably its greatest achievement. The department of antiquity is paramount and no one can dig without their permission. And they have done and continue to do a magnificent job, to the benefit of the entire Christian world. I cannot think of another country where so much of the past has been excavated and explained, over so short a time - Israel is just 60 years
For the country to be appreciated and enjoyed, some judgment has to be suspended and faith must be dominant - not difficult to do, since there are so many ardent pilgrims who truly believe. Has this trip affected my relationship with the Divine. Not sure of this - certainly it gave me a better connection to my Christian heritage.
The Palestinian territories are so interwoven with Israel, that I cannot imagine how these can be separate countries. The Palestinians and the Arabs (Jordanians) hate the Israelis. I think it is not so much a religious difference, as a territorial issue - “they have stolen our land” said a Jordan to me. America is perceived as a stupid, but powerful force that is totally behind Israel, and responsible for Israel’s aggression.
My final thoughts on this country, and particularly the city Jerusalem, that has been the source of so much bloodshed and carnage, over the last 3000 years, are negative. I cannot imagine how Jerusalem and Israel can survive, given their size and that they are surrounded by huge numbers of enemies who hate them virulently. The approach of ‘taking ten eyes or more for one eye’ while temporarily successful, cannot seem to me to create long term stability or survival.
It is said that God is Love. This seems to have been lost sight off and that is the tragedy of these beautiful biblical lands.